The Ham Hock of Liberty

Tuesday, June 06, 2006

Burning anonymous sources

Talking about the Wen Ho Lee case last night, Atrios wrote this:
Look. Cut the fucking crap already. If your sources feed you horseshit, you are under no obligation to protect them. There is no journalistic principle which says that journalists should be information launderers for those who wish to libel people.
Whether journalistic ethics or regular ethics suggest that you shouldn't out anonymous sources who've been feeding you lies is not something I'm qualified to answer. I suspect the answer is "go ahead and burn em." But journalistic ethics are not the only constraint on outing a source to whom you've promised anonymity. There's the distinct possibility of being sued, too.

Journalists have been successfully sued by anonymous sources that they outed. In Minnesota, the Star Tribune was sued by a Republican campaign operative who had been peddling stories about the opponent candidate's criminal arrest record. Although the information was true, it was somewhat misleading; the documents that the source provided showed that the other candidate had been arrested and convicted. The Strib, however, found out that one of the charges was dismissed, and the other, which did result in a conviction, was later vacated. The Strib ran the story with the angle that a GOP smear merchant was trying to fling mud on the eve of the election, and identified the source.

The source, Dan Cohen, sued the Strib, on several theories. To get to the point, the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled in favor of the paper, saying in part that the First Amendment protected what the newspaper had done. Cohen appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, which reversed the Minnesota Court, on the First Amendment issue (i.e., there's no federal constitutional protection for reporters being sued by formerly-anonymous sources). After the case was sent back down to the Minnesota Supreme Court, to be reconsidered in light of what the SCOTUS said, the Minnesota court reinstated the original judgment against the Strib, on "promissory estoppel" grounds. Basically, this theory is that Party A makes a promise to Party B. B takes (or refrains from taking) some action, in reasonable reliance on A's promise. A then breaches the promise, and B is damaged as a result. B can recover her damages from A in that situation, in most states.

Now, a few caveats apply here. First, this decision was ultimately based on Minnesota state law. Just because the First Amendment doesn't protect journalists from outing anonymous sources, doesn't mean that those sources have any right to recover damages, under applicable state law. I haven't checked the other 49 states to see if there are any similar precedents, so it could be that Minnesota is the only state in the union where this could happen.

Second, it isn't clear that the Minnesota court would have ruled the same way if Cohen was peddling deliberate lies, or even defamatory material, rather than just misleadingly-incomplete facts. That distinction wasn't addressed in the Court's remand opinion.

SO....the bottom line is, a newspaper may very well have some constraint on outing a source to whom it's promised anonymity. The Strib had to pay $200,000 for doing just that.


  • I'm not convinced that fear of legal action is their reason for not burning dodgy sources. I think it's one (or both) of two things:

    1) Even if the source is unreliable, they'd still rather get scoops from bad sources than no sources at all.

    2) They're in on the game, and the anonymous sources are simply the agreed-upon method for getting the Republican story out. They know it's horseshit from the get-go, and they JUST DON'T CARE.

    By Blogger Eli, at 11:35 AM  

  • This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    By Blogger Eli, at 11:35 AM  

  • This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    By Blogger Eli, at 11:35 AM  

  • "I'm not convinced that fear of legal action is their reason for not burning dodgy sources."

    Oh, it's -probably- not. Although I wouldn't be surprised if it was a contributing factor.

    I suspect it's more along the lines of, "Well, we can't be sure Mr. X was actually -lying- to us, he might just have been mistaken, and the facts could have been interpreted in a way so that he believed it when he told us etc. etc. etc."

    ...basically the same rationales used to excuse the Preznit about invading Iraq.

    By Blogger Nim, at 11:45 AM  

  • Heh. Eli posted three times.

    Hi Nim!

    By Blogger Vicki, at 11:53 AM  

  • vicki said...

    Heh. Eli posted three times.

    Hi Nim!

    Hello Vicki!

    And yes, Eli did post 3 times. He is a noob.

    Let's all make fun of Eli for his noobitude.

    Ha, ha, Eli!

    By Blogger Nim, at 12:07 PM  

  • Stoopit PDA Stoopit Blogger comments. *grumble grumble grumble*

    By Blogger Eli, at 3:46 PM  

  • Oh, better yet, it's apparently impossible to delete a comment from a PDA - at least not with IE...

    Argh. This is clearly a sign of the End Times.

    By Blogger Eli, at 3:53 PM  


    By Blogger Eli, at 5:34 PM  

  • "Eli said...


    You can't just declare your own victory and march away patting on yourself on the back. What are you, a Republican??

    By Blogger Nim, at 5:37 PM  

  • Hey, I have meticulously removed all forensic evidence of my triple post. If that doesn't merit a codpiece photo op on an aircraft carrier, I dunno what does.

    By Blogger Eli, at 6:53 PM  

  • Hello
    [url=]best buy[/url]
    [url=]capitalone credit card[/url]
    [url=]morgage loan calculators[/url]
    [url=]buisness credit card[/url]
    [url=]morgage loans bad credit[/url]

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:05 PM  

  • HiFriends!

    Good content and very informativity! Thanks!

    [url=]78th academy awards nude[/url]

    [url=]almost legal teen sex[/url]

    [url=]alyssa milano nude videos[/url]

    [url=]anne hathaway nude pictures[/url]
    [url=]asian gay teen sex[/url]
    best admin
    Gunter Stammler

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 6:00 AM  


    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:44 AM  

  • [url=]hoodia[/url]
    [url=]buy hoodia gordonii[/url] [url=]buy hoodia[/url] [url=]hoodia gordonii[/url] [url=]phentermine[/url] [url=]buy phentermine[/url] [url=]cheap phentermine[/url] [url=]cheapest phentermine[/url] [url=]phentermine online[/url]

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 7:52 PM  

  • Hi!
    Nice info, big thx.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:27 PM  

  • By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:41 AM  

  • Many thanks, yes I have received my full order with [url=]cheap accutane[/url] cheap accutane and [url=]hoodia[/url] hoodia. I have used other internet suppliers but you are the best of the best ! Thank you again for a brilliant product & service, [url=]buy hoodia[/url] buy hoodia and [url=]buy accutane[/url] buy accutane
    - Kindest regards, Rod

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:44 PM  

  • There are too little good sites. Your site is the best. Thank you for the chance to sign your guest book.
    - 4
    spaghetti alla carbonara

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:44 PM  

  • Respects, your site is really excellently done
    - z
    spaghetti alla carbonara

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:10 PM  

  • [url=]buy viagra[/url] [url=]buy viagra online[/url] [url=]order viagra[/url] [url=]buy viagra alternative[/url] [url=]buy viagra internet[/url] [url=]buy generic viagra online[/url] [url=]buy viagra canada[/url] [url=]buy viagra online cheap[/url] [url=]cheapest place buy viagra online[/url] [url=]where to buy viagra online[/url]
    [url=]buy cialis[/url] [url=]buy cheap cialis[/url] [url=]cheap cialis[/url] [url=]buy cialis online[/url] [url=]buy cialis generic online[/url] [url=]generic cialis[/url] [url=]generic cialis price comparison[/url] [url=]buy cheap generic cialis[/url] [url=]generic cialis online[/url]

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 6:02 PM  

  • Hi

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:22 PM  

  • Hello

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:16 PM  

  • Hi all!
    [url=]professional website design in arizona[/url]
    professional website design in arizona
    [url=]loan building materials[/url]
    loan building materials
    [url=]loan mobile telephone accessories[/url]
    loan mobile telephone accessories

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:34 AM  

  • depression drugs buy online depression drugs buy online depression drugs buy online depression drugs buy online depression drugs buy online

    depression drugs buy online
    depression drugs buy online
    depression drugs buy online
    depression drugs buy online
    depression drugs buy online

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:41 PM  

  • I lost a lot of weight by taking Phentermine that I ordered from WWW.MEDSHEAVEN.COM i am very satisfied!

    By Blogger hannah, at 4:16 AM  

  • greetings to all.
    I would first like to thank the writers of this blog by sharing information, a few years ago I read a book called costa rica investment in this book deal with questions like this one.

    By Blogger Unknown, at 5:15 PM  

  • By Blogger vuong, at 8:29 PM  

  • Hello .. firstly I would like to send greetings to all readers. After this, I recognize the content so interesting about this article. For me personally I liked all the information. I would like to know of cases like this more often. In my personal experience I might mention a book called Generic Viagra in this book that I mentioned have very interesting topics, and also you have much to do with the main theme of this article.

    By Blogger Steve, at 10:20 PM  

  • It is best to participate in a contest for among the best blogs on the web. I'll recommend this website!
    Vimax Pills Enhance VigRX Plus metropathies Male Extra Amp Do Vimax pills really work mastoidal

    By Blogger Unknown, at 1:15 AM  

  • By Blogger Unknown, at 5:54 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home